These notes accompany a lecture given by Chinmay Gupte in 2026. They summarise the key evidence and the practical messages in a form you can keep, share and come back to.
Key messages
- Cartilage restoration is not just filling a defect. Its success depends on the whole joint.
- Three things must be right first: alignment, meniscal function and ligament stability.
- A posterior meniscal root tear behaves like losing the whole meniscus, and varus alignment overloads both the cartilage and any root repair.
- Osteotomy changes the load environment. It should follow careful deformity analysis and avoid overcorrection.
- How much deformity justifies an osteotomy is still debated. Evidence supports principles, not surgical absolutes.
In plain language
Cartilage repair is like resurfacing a road: it will not last if the traffic keeps running over the same spot. If the leg is bow-legged (varus) or knock-kneed (valgus), if the meniscus cushion is torn or missing, or if the knee is unstable, a cartilage repair may wear out quickly. Surgeons therefore check the leg alignment, the meniscus and the ligaments first, and may correct them at the same time as, or before, repairing the cartilage.
Three pillars before cartilage
- Alignment – Decides where the load goes. Define compartment loading on full-length standing X-rays.
- Meniscus – Spreads load across the joint. Restore load-sharing where possible, especially the roots.
- Stability – Controls translation, rotation and shear. Treat meaningful instability.
Then cartilage: choose the cartilage procedure for a knee whose mechanics are already right.
Alignment redistributes load
| Finding | Value | Type of evidence |
| Share of load through the medial compartment in a neutral knee | Up to about 70% | Gait and instrumented implant studies |
| Extra medial load for each degree of varus | About 5% | Approximate (five patients with instrumented implants) |
| Varus above which medial osteoarthritis risk clearly rises | More than 2° | Clinical cohort |
| Peak contact pressure: neutral vs 5° varus (medial) vs 5° valgus (lateral) | About 4 vs 7.3 vs 7.8 MPa | Six cadaver knees, unstable loading |
| Meniscal extrusion in valgus vs varus | 1.32 vs 3.16 mm | Eight cadaver knees |
Normal anatomy: the tibial joint surface sits in about 3° of varus and the femoral surface in 2° to 3° of valgus. Assess where the deformity comes from (tibia or femur), not just its size.
Meniscal root tears: a functional meniscectomy
- The posterior roots anchor the meniscus so it can resist hoop stresses. In cadavers, a medial root tear raised peak medial contact pressure by 25%, similar to removing the whole meniscus, and repair restored it.
- Removing the torn meniscus does badly: after partial meniscectomy for degenerative medial root tears, 72% of patients had a knee replacement by a mean of 14 years.
- Varus works against the repair. A computer model showed medial pressures rising from 2.43 MPa at 4° valgus to 9.09 MPa at 8° varus, and beyond 4° of varus, pressure stayed high even after root repair. A laboratory study found varus increased the force on the repair, and centralisation of the meniscus reduced it.
- In patients, preoperative varus and persisting extrusion predict long-term failure of root repair, and alignment closest to neutral gives the best results.
- When varus is corrected at the same time, results in varus knees can match those in neutral knees.
Valgus and the lateral meniscus
The lateral compartment is smaller and convex, so it tolerates overload poorly. Valgus alignment predicts lateral osteoarthritis and lateral meniscal damage, even when the valgus is mild to moderate. A varus-producing distal femoral osteotomy (DFO) can be combined with a lateral meniscal transplant: in one small series, over 80% returned to sport. The evidence for valgus is thinner than for varus.
Stability: the third pillar
Ligament deficiency changes where the femur and tibia make contact and adds shear from abnormal translation and rotation. Alignment correction cannot substitute for stability. Assess the cruciate and peripheral ligaments and treat clinically relevant instability, usually at the same time as the meniscal or cartilage procedure.
Why cartilage reconstruction fails
- Alignment: focal overload continues after an anatomically perfect repair.
- Meniscus: an extruded or deficient meniscus leaves cartilage unprotected.
- Stability: instability adds abnormal motion and shear.
- Subchondral bone: poor bone support compromises fragment and graft survival.
- Biology and fixation: tissue quality and fixation strength affect healing.
- Rehabilitation: loading too much, too soon, or too little.
Failure is usually multifactorial. Look for every cause before blaming the cartilage procedure.
Osteotomy and combined surgery
A high tibial osteotomy (HTO) corrects selected varus knees and a distal femoral osteotomy (DFO) corrects selected valgus knees. Both move load away from the damaged compartment.
Planning the right osteotomy
- Measure the hip-knee-ankle angle on full-length standing radiographs.
- Find where the deformity comes from, using the medial proximal tibial angle (MPTA) and the mechanical lateral distal femoral angle (mLDFA). Correct the bone that is abnormal.
- Assess joint-line obliquity and convergence. An excessively oblique joint line shifts contact areas and meniscal loading.
- Consider tibial slope, ligament balance and patellofemoral loading.
- A common HTO target places the weight-bearing line at 50% to 55% of the tibial plateau width. With a cartilage procedure, aim for neutral to under 3° of valgus.
- Avoid overcorrection. In one series of HTO with osteochondral autograft, failure rose with larger corrections.
How much deformity justifies adding an osteotomy?
This is a genuine debate. Many surgeons reserve osteotomy for 5° or more of correctable deformity, partly because smaller corrections are technically demanding. Others add an osteotomy to a cartilage procedure whenever varus is present.
| Study | Finding |
| German cartilage registry (Faber 2020) | About 3° of varus was the main trigger for surgeons to add an HTO to medial femoral cartilage repair |
| Propensity-matched registry (Faber 2021) | Adding HTO improved function, pain and satisfaction to 3 years, but the benefit was clear only with 5° or more of varus |
| ACI with or without HTO, varus under 5° (Bode 2013) | Graft survival 89.5% with HTO vs 58.3% without (not randomised) |
| Narrative review (Mabrouk 2024) | Recommends adding an osteotomy to a planned cartilage procedure whenever there is varus |
A decision framework
Adapted from Mabrouk et al., EFORT Open Rev 2024 (Fig. 6; CC BY-NC 4.0). This is an expert proposal, not a validated decision tool. Thresholds use the MPTA and the mLDFA.
| Situation | Threshold | Suggested treatment |
| Cartilage lesion, no extra-articular deformity | MPTA over 84° and mLDFA under 90° | Cartilage procedure alone |
| Cartilage lesion plus deformity (with or without meniscal lesion) | MPTA under 85° or mLDFA over 90° | Cartilage procedure with HTO or DFO |
| Deformity, no cartilage lesion (with or without meniscal lesion) | MPTA under 81°, or mLDFA over 95° | HTO (tibial), or DFO (femoral) |
Start every pathway with examination, long-leg standing radiographs and MRI.
Will cartilage regrow after an osteotomy alone?
- Often, partly. After double-level osteotomy for severe varus, second-look arthroscopy showed regeneration over 95.7% of medial femoral condyles. With “kissing” lesions, condylar regeneration was 83% vs 79% without.
- The new tissue is mostly fibrocartilage, not normal hyaline cartilage, and it matches symptoms imperfectly.
- At 11 years, HTO alone scored as well as HTO with ACI. Adding microfracture trended towards poorer scores.
- An isolated osteotomy may be enough in degenerative varus knees. Young athletes with focal defects are a different group.
Combined osteotomy and cartilage surgery
- A systematic review of 34 studies of HTO with cartilage restoration found that patient-reported outcomes generally improved, but the studies were varied and mostly observational. Younger, carefully selected patients may do better.
- A 2026 review of 40 studies (1,783 knees) found lower failure rates when an osteotomy accompanied cartilage restoration (0% to 10.5%) than with cartilage restoration alone (0% to 41.7%).
- Osteochondral autograft (OATs) with HTO had a 13% failure rate at 5 years. OATs gave better cartilage at second look than marrow stimulation.
- With osteochondral allograft, leftover malalignment increased the risk of graft failure (hazard ratio 6.55).
- Doing the osteotomy and allograft at the same operation gave less pain at 12 months than staging them.
One stage or two?
One stage restores the axis straight away and avoids a second operation. If staging is chosen, do the bony work first so that the soft-tissue or cartilage repair is not exposed to high contact pressure. Address ligament instability and osteochondral defects at the same time where possible. Patient selection must justify the extra surgery.
HTO and meniscal root repair: is the osteotomy enough?
HTO alone can improve symptoms in varus knees with a medial root tear. Adding root repair may improve healing, and the newest meta-analysis (13 studies, 725 patients) favours combined surgery for patient-reported outcomes. However, complete root healing occurred in only a third on average, and combined repair did not consistently reduce extrusion or arthritis progression. Do not automatically add every procedure.
Checklist before cartilage surgery
- Full-length standing radiographs: hip-knee-ankle angle, MPTA, mLDFA, joint-line obliquity.
- MRI: meniscal roots, extrusion, ramp lesions, subchondral bone, opposing cartilage.
- Examination for ACL, PCL, collateral and posterolateral corner laxity.
- Decide what to correct and whether in one stage or two. If staged, bone first.
- Discuss realistic outcomes, the chance of reoperation and the rehabilitation commitment.
Important
This information is for education. It is not personal medical advice and does not replace an assessment by a qualified clinician. If you have a knee injury or symptoms, please see a doctor or physiotherapist. The evidence is summarised as it stood in November 2026 and will change as new studies appear.
References
- Ade-Conde AM, et al. Combined high tibial osteotomy and root repair improves patient-reported outcomes in medial meniscus posterior root tears. J ISAKOS. 2026;16:101035.
- Allaire R, et al. Biomechanical consequences of a tear of the posterior root of the medial meniscus: similar to total meniscectomy. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2008;90(9):1922–1931.
- Berk AN, et al. The effect of lower limb alignment on tibiofemoral joint contact biomechanics after medial meniscus posterior root repair: a finite-element analysis. J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2024;32(11):e558–e567.
- Bode G, et al. A non-randomized controlled clinical trial on ACI in cartilage defects of the medial femoral condyle with or without HTO in patients with varus deformity of less than 5°. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg. 2013;133:43–49.
- Chung KS, et al. Preoperative varus alignment and postoperative meniscus extrusion are the main long-term predictive factors of clinical failure of meniscal root repair. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2021;29(12):4122–4130.
- Daniel AV, et al. The role of alignment in treating meniscus pathology. Curr Rev Musculoskelet Med. 2025;18:149–159.
- Deichsel A, et al. Arthroscopic centralization of the medial meniscus reduces load on a posterior root repair under dynamic varus loading. Am J Sports Med. 2024.
- Dugdale TW, Noyes FR, Styer D. Preoperative planning for high tibial osteotomy. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1992;(274):248–264.
- Dzidzishvili L, et al. Combined HTO and medial meniscus posterior root repair: a systematic review. Arthroscopy. 2026.
- Faber S, et al. Decision making for concomitant HTO in cartilage repair patients. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg. 2020;140:1437–1444.
- Faber S, et al. Cartilage repair with or without additional HTO: a propensity score-matched study. Cartilage. 2021;13(1 Suppl):1206S–1216S.
- Felson DT, et al. Valgus malalignment is a risk factor for lateral knee osteoarthritis incidence and progression. Arthritis Rheum. 2013;65(2):355–362.
- Ferruzzi A, et al. Cartilage repair procedures associated with HTO in varus knees: clinical results at 11 years. Knee. 2014;21:445–450.
- Ghasemi SA, et al. High tibial osteotomy combined with cartilage restoration: a systematic review. J Clin Orthop Trauma. 2024;50:102360.
- Grassi A, et al. Am J Sports Med. 2024;52(7):1813–1819.
- Halder A, et al. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2012;94(11):1023–1029.
- Inaba HI, Arai MA, Watanabe WW. Influence of the varus-valgus instability on the contact of the femoro-tibial joint. Proc Inst Mech Eng H. 1990;204(1):61–64.
- Kim KI, et al. Mid- to long-term outcomes after medial open-wedge HTO in patients with radiological kissing lesion. Orthop J Sports Med. 2022;10:23259671221101875.
- Kim MK, Ko BS, Park JH. The proper correction of the mechanical axis in HTO with concomitant cartilage procedures. J Orthop Surg Res. 2019;14:281.
- Kumagai K, et al. Mosaic osteochondral autograft transplantation versus bone marrow stimulation with opening-wedge HTO. Arthroscopy. 2018;34:233–240.
- Lamba A, et al. Long-term outcomes of partial meniscectomy for degenerative medial meniscus posterior root tears. Orthop J Sports Med. 2024;12(9):23259671241266593.
- León SA, et al. Long-term results of fresh osteochondral allografts and realignment osteotomy for cartilage repair in the knee. Bone Joint J. 2019;101-B:46–52.
- Mabrouk A, et al. Combined knee osteotomy and cartilage procedure for varus knees: friend or foe? EFORT Open Rev. 2024;9:173–180.
- Meyer LE, et al. Concomitant procedures for knee cartilage injuries: an international Delphi consensus statement. J Cartil Jt Preserv. 2024;4(3):100198.
- Meyer LE, et al. Concomitant procedures around cartilage restoration surgery: a systematic review. Arthroscopy. 2026;42(11):2802–2814.
- Minzlaff P, et al. Osteochondral autologous transfer combined with valgus HTO: long-term results and survivorship. Am J Sports Med. 2013;41:2325–2332.
- Nakayama H, et al. Cartilage repair examined by second-look arthroscopy following double-level osteotomy. Knee. 2021;29:411–417.
- Puzzitiello RN, et al. Return to sport and outcomes after concomitant lateral meniscal allograft transplant and distal femoral varus osteotomy. Arthroscopy. 2020;36(1):253–260.
- Ridley TJ, et al. Minimum 2-year clinical outcomes of medial meniscus root tears in relation to coronal alignment. Am J Sports Med. 2022;50(5):1254–1260.
- Schipplein OD, Andriacchi TP. J Orthop Res. 1991;9(1):113–119.
- Vosoughi F, et al. HTO and concurrent medial meniscus root repair vs HTO alone: a systematic review. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2025;33:3361–3374.
- Wang D, et al. Knee joint line obliquity causes tibiofemoral subluxation that alters contact areas and meniscal loading. Am J Sports Med. 2021;49(9):2351–2360.
- Willinger L, et al. Varus alignment increases medial meniscus extrusion and peak contact pressure. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2020;28(4):1092–1098.
- Zitsch BP, et al. Patient-reported outcomes for large bipolar osteochondral allograft transplantation with realignment osteotomies. J Knee Surg. 2021;34:1260–1266.
From Knee Evidence Notes 2026 by Chinmay Gupte, PhD, FRCS (Tr & Orth), Consultant Knee Surgeon, Associate Professor, Imperial College London, and President of BASK. © 2026 Chinmay Gupte. The decision framework is adapted from Mabrouk et al., EFORT Open Reviews 2024, published under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 licence. Figures quoted are drawn from published studies, cited in the reference list, and apply to the populations studied.
